Global Training Report Archives 1997-2016

 

 

Global Training Report

From Brasil, Thailand, Japan, and Korea

Est. 2000

 

 

Book Review

Carlos Gracie: O Criador de uma Dinastia

Rio de Janeiro: Record, 2008

By Reila Gracie

Reviewed by Roberto Pedreira  

Posted March 15, 2013

 .

Chapter 3 Do Japão Para Brasil

 

Chapter 3 comprises three sections: "A Origem do Jiu-Jitsu", "O Conde Koma", and "Carlos Gracie e o Jiu-Jitsu". 

The first summarizes how Jigaro Kano transformed the battlefield arts of jiu-jitsu into the sport of judo which was less efficient for fighting. Jiu-Jitsu was in danger of disappearing completely, were it not for a fortuitous encounter between Conde Koma and Carlos Gracie in Belém do Pará in 1917. This is a familiar story, probably deriving from Dr. Helcio Binda Leal,1 one of Reyla's interviewees. It differs from the Gracie Jiu-Jitsu in Action2 version only in that it doesn't claim that the Japanese created a fake jiu-jitsu (judo) to teach to foreigners in order to hide their secret combat techniques. The important point, obviously, is that Conde Koma taught real jiu-jitsu to Carlos.

The second section reviews the life of Misuyio Esai Maeda (or Conde Koma, as he is also known, or  前田光世, his Japanese name). Reyla doesn't cite any sources for her information, but it seems generally accurate, although, according to Norio Kohyama, Maeda practiced sumo with his father before entering the Kodokan at the age of 18. He did not study "tenshin jiu-jitsu".3 Reyla also claims (p. 37) that Kodokan sent teachers to most countries in North and South America, where they met Japanese jiu-jitsu practitioners who left Japan to teach real jiu-jitsu in exotic locales rather than submit to the new Kodokan "sport" rules. This is questionable. Key to the story that will ensue, she adds "Mas de todas as sementes plantadas, somente uma vingaria, graças ao adolescente Carlos Gracie, que Maeda encontaria em  Belém do Pará [of all the seeds that would be planted, only one would thrive, thanks to the young boy Carlos Gracie, who Maeda would meet in Belém do Pará].

Reyla correctly points out that Kano gave special emphasis to throwing, but also retained arm-locks, leg locks, and chokes from various jiu-jitsu styles while eliminating the most dangerous techniques, which (it is implied) Maeda knew and taught to Carlos, and which, logically, we must assume, were  incorporated into Gracie Jiu-Jitsu. This is a necessary assumption, because without it, Maeda simply taught Carlos some basic judo techniques.4 If however Maeda taught Carlos real jiu-jitsu which was different from sportive judo, then we would not be surprised to find the Gracies later using  these lethal techniques in their matches and desafios [challenges], and teaching them in their private lessons. If we do not find techniques that are different from judo, then the foundation myth falters. 

The third section is "Carlos Gracie e o Jiu-Jitsu". No sources are cited regarding Maeda and Carlos. Since the only person who would have been in a position to witness any of this would have been Carlos himself, it is probable that Reyla's source was again Jose Geraldo's comic book A Verdade sobre os Gracie. The second half of this section concerns the family's financial and inter-personal problems.

In 1917, Gastão took Carlos, then 15 years old,  to a Maeda exhibition at the Teatro da Paz in Belém. Carlos was impressed by the victory of technique over brute force.  Maeda gave lessons on the side, like most professional wrestlers. Gastão thought that jiu-jitsu lessons might serve as an escape value for the young boy's aggressiveness. Maeda liked Carlos's insolent temperament, which Reyla thinks might have reminded Conde Koma of himself. 

Did Maeda detect a future champion in that skinny kid? Reyla wonders.  One incident suggested that he might have. Soon after his first lesson, Conde Koma asked for a student to volunteer (obviously it was a group lesson)  to be the "uke" in a demonstration of  the mystery of apparent death [misterioso da morte aparente]. No one volunteered. All of the students sat, slack-jawed in fear. Carlos was just as afraid as his fellow students, but wanted to show that he feared nothing, so he offered himself. Conde Koma began his demonstration and then stopped, saying "no Carlos, it won't be you [não Carlos, não vou fazer isso com você] ...a great champion should not begin learning jiu-jitsu while unconscious" [Não convém a uma grande campeão começar a aprender jiu-jitsu perdendo a consciência]. This left Carlos relieved but with a passion for jiu-jitsu that would last all of his life.

Seeing in that skinny blond kid [louro magricela] a future champion, Conde Koma taught Carlos more sophisticated techniques than he taught the other students and after the regular class he would ask Carlos to hang around to learn the details of the techniques.

We basically have Carlos' word for all this. But the next part is documented, which concerns Maeda's travels, and therefore his residence in Belém and therefore puts an upper limit on how long Carlos potentially could have studied with him. Maeda arrived in Belem in 1917 and left for England  the same year. In Maeda's absence, Carlos practiced with Jacinto Ferro, who taught Oswaldo and Gastão Jr. Jacinto was obviously just as much a beginner as Carlos. Carlos resumed his lessons when Maeda was available. We have no idea how often he trained. Reyla concludes that it was almost three years, but that was enough to perfect his knowledge of the mysteries of jiu-jitsu. But the evidence is not overwhelming. It consists of what Jose Geraldo said that Carlos said and the fact that Maeda was in Belém at the same time. 

We also don't know what Carlos learned, but according to Reyla,  it wasn't the traditional jiu-jitsu of Japan, nor was it the sportive jiu-jitsu moderno (judo). Reyla says that Maeda taught Carlos some of the secrets and tricks of real fighting (p. 40). These included not turning your back to your opponent,5 not letting him get the mount position and not letting him control you. Maeda did not teach inefficient judo wrist locks (???) but instead taught chokes and arm-locks to finish the fight definitively. In this way, the jiu-jitsu taught in Brazil more closely resembled the reality of a fight than the jiu-jitsu that was being taught in Europe and the USA.  

Tragedy struck the always disorganized (and as it might be said today, dysfunctional) family. Carlos's adored aunt Lindom became acutely ill with bronchitis. Before she died, she confessed that she had had intimate relations with Gastão. That revelation did nothing to improve relations between him and Cesalina. As if that weren't enough, in 1920  the American Circus, owned by Gastão, went bankrupt. He went off in search of opportunities, but without success. But on December 13, 1921, Gastão's father Pedro passed on, and Gastão, anticipating a big inheritance, packed up his bags and family and headed back to Rio.

Carlos never returned to Belém and as far as we know, had no further contact with the man who altered the course of his life, although he easily could have, because Conde Koma stayed in Belém and was a well-known person in Brazil up until the time of his death in 1941.

 

NEXT WEEK

Chapter 4. Rio de Janeiro, Capital do Brasil

Previous Chapters

 

Notes

1. Helcio Binda Leal's version can be found here. Keep in mind that it has been modified by Reyson Gracie and may not accurately reflect Dr. Leal's opinions..

2. According to Rorion, “the Japanese always wanted to hide the ancient techniques of jiu-jitsu. That’s what originated the idea of judo, just the sportive aspect of the traditional jiu-jitsu.” 

3. ライオンの夢:前田光世 [Raion no Yume: Maeda Mitsuyo], by Norio Kohyama  1997. Tokyo: Shogakukan. Since Kano had studied tenjinshinyo-ryu (and other styles), and his Kodokan judo was a synthesis of many arts, and tenjinshinyo-ryu itself was, according to Syd Hoare (2009, p. 45), "an amalgam of the Yoshin-ryu and Shin no Shinto-ryu," it is very likely that Maeda acquired whatever tenjinshinyo-ryu techniques  he knew via Kodokan judo (or from people with Kodokan connections). For more details see A History of Judo. by Syd Hoare, London: Yamagi Books, 2009. What they were and whether he taught them to Carlos is of course a different and unsubstantiated matter. Reyla doesn't throw any light on it in this chapter, and indeed, somewhat confuses things.

4. Which is what Rorion and Helio claim. See this Helio interview for one example.

5. Not letting an opponent take your back sounds like common sense in 2013, but it wasn't always. In a tape made sometime during the late 1980's, shooto champion Erik Paulson, who had taken some lessons with a number of the Gracies, told his training partner Chad Stahelski, "The Gracies say 'never turn your back to your opponent'". Chad was a shooto fighter, and instructor at the Inosanto Academy, and all-around impressive martial artist (also Hollywood actor and stuntman), but he continually gave his back and repeatedly got choked. "Keep your hands up" is also common sense, but if everyone did it no one would get knocked out.

 

 

(c) 2013, Roberto Pedreira. All rights reserved.

 

 

 

GTR Publications

 

 

 

 

Choque 1, 3rd Edition (June 1, 2016)

 

 

 

Choque 3, 1961-1999

(Updated June 1, 2016)

 

 

 

 

Choque 2, 1950-1960 

 (Updated June 16, 2016)

 

 

 

A1SZprint.jpg (145051 bytes)

Jiu-Jitsu in the South Zone, 1997-2008 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Digital Editions are also available

GTR Archives 1997-2016